Abstract
Diagnostic tests play a central role in clinical decision-making, yet substantial variation exists in how physicians use diagnostic resources, even when treating clinically similar patients. Prior research suggests that such variation is influenced more by physicians’ characteristics and contextual factors than by objective clinical need (Hartley et al., 1987; Vinker et al., 2007; Wennberg, 2010). This study examines whether physicians’ diagnostic test ordering behavior is associated with physician gender and years of experience, while explicitly accounting for real-time operational workload. Using patient-level retrospective electronic medical record data from outpatient units of a large training and research hospital, we analyze 119,254 patient visits generated by 42 physicians across five specialties. We employ random-effects negative binomial regression models to account for over-dispersed diagnostic test counts and unobserved physician-level heterogeneity. The results show that both physician experience and physician gender are significant predictors of diagnostic test ordering behavior: more experienced physicians and female physicians order a higher number of diagnostic tests per patient, holding patient characteristics, diagnoses, specialty, time effects, and workload constant. In addition, diagnostic test ordering increases with real-time waiting load and decreases with completed workload and progression through the clinic session, consistent with theories of cognitive load and decision fatigue (Kahneman, 2011) as well as hypothetico-deductive decision-making method (Hausmann et al., 2016). These findings contribute to the literature on medical practice variation by demonstrating that diagnostic test use is a behavioral and context-dependent outcome shaped by physician heterogeneity and operational conditions, with implications for decreasing the practice variations with behavioral evidence-based and workload-aware interventions aimed at reducing unnecessary diagnostic testing.