Abstract
The study seeks to explore line managers’ contribution to the implementation gap in voice-related HR practices. A national case study methodology was adopted involving interviews with 35 line managers, senior managers and HR in the Malawi public utilities. The study found that grievance procedure was the formal voice mechanism, but it was being avoided by employees who preferred voicing through the informal alternative voice mechanism which emerged. Line managers contributed to this voice gap because, instead of practicing their conduit roles such as enforcing voice policy compliance, sensitising subordinates on the grievance procedure and torchbearer in grievance procedure, they practiced adaptability roles which exacerbated the voice gap. For example, they applied humanistic approach in enforcing voice policy compliance, emphasised respectful voice and discouraged destructive voice in grievance procedure sensitisation and defended management instructions while denying eye to subordinate issues in their torchbearer role. Consistent with an Ability, Motivation and Opportunity (AMO) understanding of line managers’ implementation of HRM practice, this was found to be because of limited HR guidance, limited voice facilitation resources, lack of voice facilitation training, lack of empowerment and lack of policy knowledge. It was also found to result from structural, cultural, and material constraints of the public sector in the Malawi national context. The study contributes to the multi-layered conceptualisation of employee voice, creation of an account of line managers’ role in the HRM implementation process, and understanding of how unique features of a non-western national and public sector context explain line managers’ implementation of voice-related HR practices. The study has implications for managerial practice in a non-western African and public sector context.