Abstract
Caring leadership has emerged as a compelling approach in fostering employee wellbeing. When it becomes a norm, and therefore part of organizational culture, it also has the potential to raise performance levels. Our study contributes to the literature by presenting a model of the inter-woven relationships between leadership, organizational culture, performance, and wellbeing. Findings from our qualitative investigation of the New Zealand hospitality and tourism sector, which has been severely challenged by the Covid-19 pandemic, reveal how demonstrations of care from the organization as a whole, and from individual leaders, had a considerable impact on employee performance and wellbeing. The study also underscores the downside of caring leadership, particularly for leaders. This double-edged sword has implications for practice, regarding what organizations can do to develop caring leadership as a key element of the culture, but also to train and support leaders in danger of burnout from caring for others.