Abstract
Recent scholarship on the performance of infrastructure projects against plan has accepted the “iron law of megaprojects” to the effect that they are “over budget, over time, over and over again". Whether due to delusion or deception in a psychological dynamic, the socio-economic implications are the same – outturn performance of asset delivery systematically exceeds expected performance at FID with consequential welfare losses for economy and society. At first glance, it appears that HS2 – the proposed high speed rail network to the north of London – is testimony to the iron law. The cancellation of the whole of Phase 2 of HS2 in October 2023 sent shockwaves through the UK infrastructure sector. While the proximate cause of the cancellation was budget escalation, we show that the underlying problem is one of the escalation of budget and schedule generated by the interactions between the stakeholders to the project in an organizational rather than psychological dynamic distorted by the investment appraisal process required by UK government.