Abstract
Shifts in the UK regulatory environment have expanded the role of Trading Standards inspectors beyond enforcement to include advisory support for small firms. This evolution, shaped by austerity and localism, generates tensions between compliance enforcement and business support. Using paradox theory and street-level bureaucracy, this study examines how inspectors navigate these tensions through discretionary strategies. Drawing on 17 interviews with Trading Standards inspectors across four UK locations, the findings identify four persistent challenges: dual role conflict, resource constraints, divergent client expectations, and central-local policy discrepancies. Rather than alternating between enforcement and support, inspectors integrate both functions adaptively, employing graduated enforcement, targeted engagement, and cost-recovery models to manage contradictions. The study contributes to regulatory studies by demonstrating that discretion is not merely reactive but a structured governance tool. It offers insights for policymakers on designing frameworks that balance regulatory integrity with business support, ensuring effective compliance while addressing the constraints of contemporary regulatory practice.