Abstract
Social enterprises play a vital role in addressing unfulfilled societal challenges and fostering a more inclusive, sustainable future. Yet, despite their potential to create significant social value, these organisations often struggle to attract top-tier talent due to their comparatively modest remuneration packages. Drawing on signalling theory, this study posits that job candidates will perceive higher organisational attractiveness and exhibit stronger cognitive-creative performance during recruitment processes when the Chief Executive Officer (CEO) demonstrates charismatic leadership and the firm’s mission statement explicitly aligns with its social objectives.
To investigate this proposition, we conducted field scenario-based experiments employing video treatments in which a CEO delivered a welcoming speech. Using a 2 (charismatic vs. neutral leadership style) × 2 (mission statement either highlighting or omitting explicit social initiatives) between-subjects design with 125 participants, we examined the effects of charismatic leadership on organisational attractiveness and cognitive-creative test performance through the mediators of anticipated pride and perceived value fit, alongside the moderating influence of explicit corporate social initiatives. Our experimental manipulations were successful, confirming the rigour of the research design. While no direct link emerged between entrepreneurial charisma and prospective employees’ cognitive-creative test performance, findings indicate that entrepreneurial charisma significantly boosts such performance when the firm’s mission explicitly underscores social initiatives. By investigating how entrepreneurial charisma and corporate social initiatives act as signalling mechanisms, this research demonstrates the importance of alignment between leadership style and mission statement in enhancing organisational appeal and imbuing prospective employees with a greater sense of societal impact. These insights offer valuable guidance for both scholars and practitioners seeking to strengthen talent recruitment and retention in socially driven enterprises.