Abstract
This study investigates how organisations manage their ‘commitment to history’ when facing legitimacy challenges in pluralistic and dynamic environments. While existing legitimacy research has largely centred on conformity, the commitment problem, which concerns how organisations manage ‘commitment to history’, defined as consistency in actions and values over time, remains underexplored. To address this gap, we conduct a historical case study of two department stores in semi-colonial China: Hall & Holtz and Wing On. Both occupied a ‘middle ground’ distinct from multinational corporations and local enterprises, and faced legitimacy challenges as rising nationalism increasingly challenged the global capitalism to which they were originally aligned. Drawing on historical sources, we identify two distinct strategies for managing commitment to history: symbolic commitment reinforcement and adaptive commitment modification. This study advances legitimacy management theory by offering new insights into the commitment problem and organisations’ strategic balance between commitment and conformity.