Abstract
This paper examines the role serving culture plays in Machiavellian leaders adopting the appearance of servant leadership and whether followers detect that behaviour as insincere, impacting followers’ moral disengagement. Data were collected through online surveys, with 181 followers and 75 leaders participating in South African organisations. Although there was no direct relationship between leader Machiavellianism and follower-rated servant leadership behaviour, serving culture moderated the association such that the relationship was positive. Additionally, servant leadership was related to lower levels of follower moral disengagement. This study added a boundary condition to a previously observed positive Machiavellianism/servant leadership relationship and added a follower outcome to the servant leadership nomological network. Practically, organisations looking to promote a serving culture through servant leadership development programs are advised to pay attention to emphasizing the other-centred beliefs underpinning the leadership style, encouraging the authentic adoption of servant leadership behaviour instead of an insincere appearance thereof.