Abstract
This paper explores the hegemonic sustainability imaginary through investigating the ideological assumptions reproduced in sustainability studies published in leading business journals. While there is a broadening consensus that we must transition towards more “sustainable” ways of doing business, the inexorable advance of climate change suggests that we are failing at doing so. We suggest that this failure can be traced to the ideological hegemony propagated by the dominant intellectual class (Gramsci, 1974). This hegemony is maintained through publications in leading business journals which act as central gatekeepers in the circulation of popular sustainability ideas.
Based on an interdisciplinary review of sustainability studies published in leading journals, the present paper exposes the assumptions underlying the ‘right-orientation environmentalism’ (Foster, 2014) characterizing the hegemonic sustainability imaginary. These assumptions reinforce the denial of radical change solutions pointed out by other scholars (Wright et al., 2013, Nyberg and Wright, 2022, Banerjee et al., 2021, Milne et al., 2006, Butler and Loacker, 2022), whilst preventing alternative ideological positions to enter mainstream conversations. Yet to survive the imminent environmental collapse (Bendell, 2018), a radical transformation of the existing socio-economic organization is paramount (Nyberg and Wright, 2022). This requires alternative ideological positions advocating for radical change to effectively spread from the fringes to the mainstream of business research. This paper is therefore an attempt to arouse the critical spirit of mainstream business research which has been confined to its subconscious by the hegemonic imaginary.