Abstract
Aspiring to and deciding to devote one’s work life to an academic career is as Weber (1922) expresses based on a commitment and a calling. Academic work is embedded with certain standards and values in the specific research area, the host institution and the wider research community. However, in later years external demands seems to limit the academics’ autonomy putting the academic freedom under threat. The paper departs from the significant changes in the management of higher education institutions, which have entailed a transformation from academic driven universities towards managerial universities over the last couple of years. Through a longitudinal study of the on-going use of quality and relevance in the formulation of the faculty strategy, this paper aims to elucidate how the values gained agency and authority throughout the strategy implementation process affecting the constitution of legitimate and aspirational academic practice and providing the ground for managerial decision. To this endeavor the paper proceeds firstly by examining the constitutive process whereby the meanings of quality and relevance became (re)negotiated and temporarily fixed. In other words, how the values as empty signifiers became filled with meaning. Secondly, the paper investigates how quality and relevance - acting as non-human agents – were attributed and appropriated decisive actions (like dismissing staff or closing research units and study programs) in the strategy process (Bencherki and Cooren, 2011). The paper shows how the attribution of decisive actions displaces the responsibility of burdensome and unpopular decisions from the management or management consultants (the human agent) unto the values, principles, strategies, visions, etc. (non-human agents), which is opening the gateway to massive loss of managerial accountability.
Please choose your submission type
Developmental Paper
Primary Track
Critical Management Studies