British Academy of Management
Knowledge tension derives from knowledge sharing/transfer to create value and knowledge safeguarding/protection to prevent simultaneous knowledge spillover—two interdependent and contradictory forces. Tension is common in interorganizational collaboration. Some studies claim that knowledge tension results in paradox and conflict among partners, hindering collaborative performance. However, other studies have affirmed the positive impact of knowledge tension on collaborative performance. What is the actual impact of knowledge tension on collaborative performance? To resolve the ongoing controversies among the theoretical arguments and empirical results in the literature, this study demonstrates that the stronger the knowledge tension is, the greater the attractiveness to partners and the higher the potential for value creation. Thus, knowledge tension may have a positive impact on collaborative performance for knowledge complementarity. This positive relationship is strengthened by the functions of the management mechanisms (structural ambidexterity and contextual ambidexterity). Our empirical results—based on data from 153 firms involved in vertical and horizontal collaboration, collected via questionnaires—confirm our hypotheses.