Abstract
Despite the widespread promotion of Agile methods in the literature, there is limited empirical evidence to support the claim that Agile is superior to other project management methods. Additionally, little is known about the best methods and practices to support Agile success. This paper presents a subgroup analysis of a large dataset to explore the effectiveness of Agile methods in various project types. The results indicate that Agile methods are more successful than traditional methods, particularly in projects with experienced teams, medium to low stakeholder engagement, smaller team sizes, and unclear goals. However, the effectiveness of Agile methods is limited in low complexity projects with clear goals, high stakeholder engagement, large teams, or inexperienced teams. Nonetheless, teams benefit from adopting Agile methods, even if their project does not fit the ideal Agile use case. The popularity and growth of Agile methods are therefore justified.