Abstract
Introducing sustainability within an organisation's strategic priorities can lead to tensions between the established strategy and the newly introduced sustainability goals. This tension is challenging for innovation portfolio management that needs to implement the company’s strategy through innovation projects. Although organisational tensions could be positive for innovation portfolios, how to approach them remains unclear. Through paradox theory, we hypothesize that two organisational characteristics (i.e., entrepreneurial orientation and innovation climate) can trigger a paradoxical management approach and ultimately be advantageous for innovation portfolios. Using a multi-informant cross-industry sample of 97 innovation portfolios, we find that tensions alone neither show a positive nor negative relationship to a portfolio’s innovativeness. However, entrepreneurial orientation and an innovation climate moderate this relationship so that tensions positively relate to portfolio innovativeness when entrepreneurial orientation and innovation climate are high and negatively when they are low. Our study contributes to the literature on sustainability in innovation management.