Abstract
The performance of public versus private ownership has for decades been a frequent discussion point, both in the public debate and in the academic literature on sector differences. While some authors claim that privately owned organisations achieve a higher level of performance than publicly owned organisations, others argue that no evidence of this exists and that the performance of publicly and privately owned organisations is incomparable due to differences in performance criteria.
This paper seeks to provide a fresh perspective on the public versus private ownership debate by comparing the performance of publicly and privately owned IT projects through six different operationalisations of performance. IT project performance is specifically chosen as a proxy for organisational performance because it is a highly comparable type of performance that exists within all varieties of publicly and privately owned organisations, which makes it an ideal choice for comparing the performance of public and private ownership.
The paper analyses survey data on 49 publicly owned and 102 privately owned IT projects complemented by hard data on project costs, schedules and benefits. The data is analysed using classical frequentist hypothesis tests as well as Bayes factors. In addition to ensure the validity of the results, the data used is compared against a larger dataset, consisting of data on 6,003 IT projects. On this basis, the authors argue that the results can be used for drawing analytical inferences.
The results of the analyses are mixed; while the projects under private ownership show a significantly higher level of performance in terms of achieving the intended impact and the expected end user system adaption, performance measures in terms of stakeholder performance evaluations and schedule performance show no performance difference between publicly and privately owned projects. Finally, comparisons of cost and benefit performance yield non-significant results. The authors interpret the results as evidence of no overall difference in the level of achieved performance between publicly and privately owned organisations.