Abstract
The ‘deficit’ model of learning is well recognised for its role in determining which students do, or don’t go university and which universities they are more likely to attend, the model is also recognised for the effect this has on how institutions are ranked, and values ascribed. While this is not new territory, in our paper we take this argument further; proposing that the assumptions behind the deficit model have also come to underpin the ways in which the staff who work in those universities are governed and valued, with important consequences for staff retention, engagement and sense of fulfilment. Further, we raise the possibility that the move to a market-informed ethos that is grounded in a model of education premised on ‘elitist’ metrics such as research quality and graduate outcomes is a vehicle which perpetuates this impact and provides a focus that may divert attention from the organisational and leadership contexts that affect workplace efficacy and well-being. Essentially, we suggest that staff and student deficit models co-exist in educational settings which are designed to address disadvantage in some form or another, and we reflect on how this is influenced by the wider economic and political drivers that HEIs must accommodate and respond to. Finally, we seek to explore the implications for widening participation institutions.