Abstract
The current discourse around craft is dominated by a view of craftwork being ‘good’ work that has even been said hold potential for changing the alienating nature of the capitalist labour process. However, there is a small yet increasing number of contributions that sit unwell with this dominant narrative (e.g., Delgaty & Wilson, 2023; Fox Miller, 2019; Kovesi & Kern, 2018; Munro & O’Kane, 2022). This article aims to better understand these alternative views by examining craftwork in a traditional context. We first describe the firm at hand, an Italian SME producing high-end pipes. We show that it engages both in an active telling of the craft narrative as well as in certain craft practices. Then, we examine the organization’s working conditions, finding them to be poor, and consequently ask how the craft narrative can act as a resource to foster worker consent in this context. Drawing on Burawoy (2012), we then show how the craft narrative provides a resource for workers to find ‘small gains and the relative satisfactions they bring’ (p. 195). We propose that the craft narrative may function as a mystifying ideology (Burawoy, 1982) that works through the fetishisation of the materiality and aesthetics of craft products (cf. Dant, 1996).