Abstract
This paper draws on Judith Butler's notion of giving an account of oneself, applied to a study of frontline security officers ('FSOs') working in the UK private security sector, to investigate issues of precarity, agency, and the reproduction of marginalisation. We show how FSOs construct a narrative in which they validate themselves as 'helping' professionals. We argue that such a narrative demonstrates individual agency that resists negative tropes that permeate established discourses of private security. However, we contend that structurally, the narrative is problematic because 'helping' is discursively associated with feminised labour and subordination, and because caring competencies have historically been devalued. Furthermore, FSOs’ precarity is further entrenched because formal regulation, although having a sanctioning effect, fails to generate esteemed recognition. The paper therefore engages with questions of the ‘dark side’ of regulatory mechanisms ostensibly set up to ameliorate marginalisation.