Abstract
Organizations often struggle to achieve all intended strategic objectives, partly due to incomplete internal implementation and external reactions. Research highlights middle managers (MMs) as crucial to strategy execution, emphasizing their motivations, autonomy, and role in implementation. While previous studies recognize the importance of top manager-middle manager (TM-MM) relationships, few directly analyze these dyads alongside other factors influencing MM deviations from intended strategies. This study focuses on TM-MM relationships in strategic changes related to digitalization, servitization, and sustainability in 20 Italian manufacturing firms. Social exchange theory suggests that stronger TM-MM relationships enhance implementation. Using both qualitative coding of interview text and quantitative fuzzy set Qualitative Comparative Analysis (fsQCA) and MAXQDA, preliminary findings indicate that while TM-MM relationship quality is significant, other factors—such as external environmental dynamism, MM involvement in strategy formulation, and MM strategic influence and autonomy—also play key roles. The study concludes by exploring how social exchange theory complements other frameworks in understanding MM-led strategy implementation.